Would you rather…Read or Watch?

Today’s blog post is going to cover the topic of Book Versus Movie/Television. The reason for this debate (or rather, why I have my panties in a twist) is because I watched the new TV Series ‘Midnight, Texas’ based off the book series by Charlaine Harris.

Let me first give you some background info: I read all the Sookie Stackhouse books and watched one or two episodes of True Blood on HBO.  (I probably would have watched more, but we didn’t get HBO at the time because we’re too cheap to pay for it and now I’m too lazy to rent the series on DVD).  I have read NONE of the Midnight, Texas books.  Evidently there are three books in the series.

So I DVR’d the Midnight, Texas television show and decided I’d give it a chance. I knew I liked the author and I love shows with a paranormal element.  After the first fifteen minutes I was hooked.  The show started with a whopper of an action scene and immediately grabbed my attention.  However, my mind began to wander as the episode progressed and I felt like I was missing out on valuable information that was most likely in the book, but cut out of the television show in order to save on time.  In the end, I decided that I’d be better off just reading the books and not waiting for a whole season of shows to find out what happens.

This brings me to our topic of today…do you all agree with me? Would you rather read a story and picture it in your head as the drama unfolds…or would you rather let it play out on television or at the movie theater?  I would honestly have to say that I prefer the books in 90% of situations.

Let’s take a stroll down memory lane for some prime examples of stuff I’ve read and then watched.

Example #1   THE STAND by STEPHEN KING.  This is my favorite book in the history of books.  The man tells a narrative and sets a scene like nobody’s business.  I didn’t feel the miniseries did it justice.

Example #2 The Twilight Series.  By the time the fourth book was released, I had seen the movie and couldn’t help but picture Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart as Edward and Bella.  The fact that they were both in the tabloids every five seconds kind of removed some of the excitement of the story for me.

Example #3 Fifty Shades of Grey. I suffered through all the books (yes, Anastasia, please bite your lip ONE MORE TIME) and had no real desire to see Mr. Grey make a brooding ‘I want to spank you’ face for two hours on film.  But…we had free HBO that weekend, so I DVR’d it anyway.  (Yes, I have a problem with watching TV live in real time.  I like to DVR stuff so I can fast forward.  I hate commercials and have a short attention span!)  Wow.  I ended up skipping most of the sex scenes and laughing every time Christian Grey scowled.

Example #4  Harry Potter.  This is the one exception to the rule of my preference for books over movies.  I would have to say that both of them were equally mesmerizing. While it’s true that I prefer to picture the characters in my head, and it’s always a disappointment when the actors cast in the role do not match up, I have no problem with Harry, Hermione, or Ron.  I think JK Rowling did such an amazing job with her world building and stayed true to her characters.

I guess there’s nothing quite like the feeling when you’re totally engrossed in a good book, transported to another world, and get so absorbed that you block out everything going on in real life. I can do that a lot easier when I’m reading than when I’m watching.

That’s just my opinion, but I’m interested to know what you think of the topic.  What movies did you find to be better than the books?

Til next time….



5 thoughts on “Would you rather…Read or Watch?

  1. I am reading the Midnight Texas books now too I just started today, I have recorded the 1st ep of the series I always have to read the books before I watch a tv show or film based on it, I like to have the real version of events straight in my head before I get the twisted made for ratings version.
    The books like you say are almost always better I can’t think of any instance at the moment were the adaptation is better. There is always times where they add stuff in for effect and sometimes it falls hideously flat and sometimes it is an amazing fit to the story. But the worst is when they leave out really important information for further down the series and it really sends me crazy! Like the whole house elf story in harry potter they were such a big part of the books and we saw almost nothing 😦
    I love both watching shows/movies and reading books, shows are for entertainment but I love to get sucked right in and books are what do that, books grab you and make you apart of them. Books are for immersing yourself in, for living in,


      1. Finished the first one, it’s very slow. I have seen the adverts for the tv show and let me just say this… I have no idea how they got that from this book, hopefully they will get better. I will be diving into book two later


  2. I have to say I mostly agree with you Especially with the Charlaine Harris books. they completely rewrote True Blood so you hardly recognized Sookie Stackhouse. have neither read or watched the Nightshift series, but have it on my tbr list.

    I have to say you were braver than I when it came to Fifty Shades. I can say I read the books. Want nothing more to do with it. As for the rest, I have read and watched the movies on all of them, I find if I watch the movies first,I can enjoy them. Then I can read the books and pick up what I missed.Works for me, mostly.


    1. This is a good point…if you watch the movies first and then read the books, the movies won’t be as disappointing because you’re going in ‘fresh’ with no expectations. Good idea!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.